Churned this morning

Butterfat

Small-batch ice cream made with cream from a dairy twenty minutes up the road. Twelve flavours at a time, never more, always fresh.

A strawberry ice cream cone held up against a yellow wall

The shop

A scoop counter, not a factory

Butterfat is one churning machine, two freezers and a counter on Erie Street. Everything in the case was made in this room, most of it this week.

We keep the case small on purpose. Twelve tubs means every flavour gets eaten fresh, and there is always something new to argue about.

A gelato display case filled with tubs of fresh flavours

The week in cream

Every tub takes three days

  1. Day oneCook

    We roast, steep or caramelize the flavour base. Strawberries get an hour in the oven before they ever meet cream.

  2. Day twoAge

    The base rests overnight in the cooler. Aging lets the fat bloom, so the scoop lands dense and smooth instead of icy.

  3. Day threeChurn

    Small batches, low overrun, straight into the blast freezer and out to the case the same afternoon.

In the case right now

This week's dozen, previewed

A deep purple scoop of ube ice cream on a spoon
Ube coconutPurple yam, toasted coconut
Scoops of peach ice cream in a bowl with a spoon
Peach & thymeCounty peaches, fresh herb
Strawberry popsicles with fresh raspberries
Berry popsWhole fruit, no dye
Vanilla scoops rolled in rainbow sprinkles on a cake stand
Birthday vanillaMadagascar bean, sprinkles